Resisting surveillance capitalism: democracy in a digital world

Chair of Digital Rights Watch, Lizzie O’Shea, addressed the NSW Council of Civil Liberties in October. We republish her speech with permission. She shows how with the industrial revolution in England modern policing emerged to surveil and control the working class.

In modern times she sees technology accelerating the control of executive power over parliament.

Lizzie O’Shea addresses the NSW Council of Civil Liberties Annual Dinner 2026. Photo: NSW CCL

I’ve always been a little wary of the Margaret Mead quote, about how a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens is the only thing that ever has ever changed the world.

I’ve always been a much more fond of the Thomas Paine view: “Those who expect to reap the blessings of freedom, must undergo the fatigues of supporting it.” The defence of civil liberties is not something a small group of clever people impose on everyone else, that’s the flip side of a free society. It is about convincing lots of people of the benefits of a free and fair society so that they feel invested in defending it.  

I think the history of the NSW Council of Civil Liberties demonstrates this is spades: routinely finding ways to bring people along the journey of defending civil liberties, being undaunted in taking up sometimes unpopular causes, creating a consistency which strengthens the moral authority for use in moments when it matters.

I was asked to speak about the modest topic: protecting democracy in an increasingly digital world.

My experience in recent years has been on digital technology and democracy, and these concepts are in the most significant amount of tension they have been in for two centuries.

When I was thinking about what I wanted to talk about, I was wondering where to start. In my book Future Histories, my goal was to talk about technology not as some kind of divine of ghostly phenomenon that imposes itself onto society, but something that is a human creation with a human history.

My aim was to show that historical thinkers and movements from the past have relevance to understanding debates about technology today. That in fact, rather than unprecedented or novel, a lot of the conversations we have about technology and it’s impact on our society and democracy in the 21st century are questions many people have grappled with before.

Given I’m speaking to civil rights people, I thought the best place to start was with the creation of the first modern professional police force. For a long time, I’d assumed professionalised policing was standard feature of human society, but when I researched my book I realised the history was less straightforward.

Origins of modern policing

Painting of 19th century police boarding a ‘suspicious boat’ on the Thames. Source: West India Committee

In fact, the first experiments with professionalised policing that we might recognise today was in the late 18th century on the docks of the River Thames. It should come as no surprise that this was a moment of technological disruption and advancement (in the form of the industrial revolution) where the social order and economic organisation was in a state of transformation.

The Marine Police Office was a pilot program to establish a professional body that would monitor and enforce the strictures of waged labour against the dock workers who were struggling and resisting the confines of this new form of social organisation. The merchants were sick of losing stock to workers who saw it as their right to top up their wages, and they pooled their funds to establish a project proposed by three men: John Harriott (a magistrate), Patrick Colquhoun (a statistician), and the famed utilitarian Jeremy Bentham. The first modern police force was as a collaboration between industry and the state to operationalise – quite explicitly – a form of surveillance of everyday people at scale.

Colquhoun wrote about his experiment on the River Thames extensively. His vision of policing was deeply bound to economics. He described policing as “a new Science … in the Prevention and Detection of Crimes…

“It is the dread of the existing power of immediate detection, and the certainty of punishment as the consequence of this detection,” wrote Colquhoun, “that restrains men of loose morals from the commission of offences.”

Surveillance, plus the spectacle of force, offered an economical and effective way of maintaining order. It is not walls, locks or bars that prevent crime, Colquhoun argued; instead, “restraints are only to be effected by the strong and overawing hand of power”.

The theory, and the experiment was a raging success, significantly reducing the merchants’ losses for a small price.

Harriott, Colquhoun and Bentham went on to convince Westminster to support

the project, and the Marine Police Office came under state authority two years later. Now, not only did the merchants have a police force, it was funded by the public purse.

The history of policing helps us understand some key aspects of statecraft in the digital age. Like their historical counterparts, modern police understand the power of surveillance in enforcing a form of discipline. Safety is about preserving social order, rather than reducing harm. By allowing law enforcement and intelligence agencies to tell us what it is to be safe, we allow them to use technology in increasingly oppressive ways.

Over the last two centuries, we have seen this pattern repeated:

  1. Rapid technological advances have been accompanied by disruptive transformations in social relations, and acceleration of policing has often been the response. In essence, the social fall out of technological change has been met with the strong and overawing hand of power closing into a fist to crush resistance.

And in the 21st century:

  • We are seeing this play out in more intensive and invasive ways, where advances in technology are not just in tension with civil liberties, but increasingly challenging our society at a more fundamental level.

Surveillance is being used to manage the fall out of technological transformation and technology itself is serving to consolidate power in state and corporate forms in ways that undermine not just civil liberties but our democracy.

Over the past two decades, we have seen this shift, as technology has continued to advance corporate and state surveillance, poison our information ecosystem and concentrate corporate power to a degree not seen since the Gilded age.

This has correlated with an expansion of surveillance capabilities. The New York Times described Australia as the “world’s most secretive democracy” with good cause. In the last two decades, we have passed more than 100 different bills in the wake of the war on terror, by some counts over 875 different offences and, at its height, this was a new bill every six weeks. On average, the parliament had how many days to consider these bills? A mere five. In one instance, for the crossbench at least, it was a single afternoon.

So, a stripping away of parliamentary power, with its attenuating scrutiny, towards a growing executive power – one of which increasingly relies on technology and the technology industry.

Technology companies, many of them in the business of surveillance capitalism themselves, have been overwhelmingly compliant as their business models have been repurposed for state surveillance ambitions. Some of the most controversial laws in recent years, such as the metadata retention regime and the Access and Assistance Act (aimed at introducing weaknesses to encryption systems) have sought to make use of existing systems of surveillance capitalism and repurpose them for state surveillance.

This is still happening today. In July, the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor raised a whole range of concerns about the overreach inherent in this body of law and the chilling effect on freedom of political communication and the press. Just a month later, the government was proposing to make a range of controversial powers for ASIO permanent.

Equally, the failure to regulate, or pass laws, has been highly revealing of the ways in which technology has become central to modern forms of surveillance. Privacy law reform has mostly withered on the vine for the last five years (although I’m pleased to say that has recently changed), hard regulation of artificial intelligence has been effectively abandoned, and facial recognition technology has remain stubbornly unregulated, despite clear mandates for reform.

In places like Europe, the use of real-time facial recognition technology by law enforcement is prohibited on the basis of it being too dangerous, but it’s just another everyday use of technology if you’re in Western Australia. The US has seen significant number of court cases considering the specific circumstances in which an officer can search a person’s phone, in NSW police.

Undoubtedly this is a function of being the only liberal democracy without a bill of rights. Laws can be passed with minimal consideration of human rights, the public debate is atrophied by a lack of discussion about the role of rights and how they might need to be balanced and managed (and be subject to redress as required). We have successive ambitious governments who see pro-law enforcement policies as an easy poll bump, and are too timid or cynical to resist overtures from national security bodies for more and more powers to surveil and police in more and more ways.

Undoubtedly this is also a function of an industry that is hugely powerful and is shaped by its own sense of politics and grandiosity. I feel like I could talk about this forever, but I only really have time to give you a small taste.

Meta continues to fill our social media feeds with harmful content and AI slop – they make up to 10% of their revenue from ads they have 90% confidence are scams. They also allow nudification technology and products to be advertised on their platforms, even in defiance of the law and on occasion targeting children. Our response is to criminalise the children that use this rather than those who profit from its distribution. Meta also sells smart glasses impervious to the risk of harm for vulnerable people. These are the Jeffrey Epstein of consumer products, a device for people who don’t believe in consent, which contributes to a broader culture along similar lines.

SpaceX (it’s hard to pick the worst thing this company has done) has built one of the dirtiest and obscene data centres in the world, called Colossus, renting out US$1.5bn a month worth of capability to the AI company everyone likes to pretend is ethical, Anthropic. They of course have also built an image generator which is commonly used to create non-consensual sexually explicit material.

Our friends at ‘don’t be evil’ land, Google, are collaborating with militaries all over the world to build out targeting and intelligence systems. These have been used in theatres of war and genocide, like Iran and Gaza, by the US and Israeli militaries.

The worst part is, I’m not entirely convinced these people think they are doing anything wrong. Need I mention Palantir, a company that specialises in in data analytics, which in practice means matching up data sets to identify people for deportation by ICE, as one such example. Peter Thiel, founder of Palantir, recently claimed: “If you’re evil, you’re at least competent. And if you’re evil, you’re not bad. And therefore, maybe you’re actually kind of good because you’re at least getting something done.” That’s on [fact-checking website] Snopes because it seems such a ludicrous thing to say, but he said it.

These aren’t just consumer tech companies, they are artificial intelligence companies and there is a lot at stake in keeping them growing.

Recent economic analysis found that the current spending on AI by the market is dwarfing previous historic capex booms, including the dawn of the railroad era and the internet. The US economy, economists suggest, would be at a standstill if we took out the growth of AI companies and data centre builds. 

My point of all this is to say this is a small group of people with enormous financial power, who harbour anti-democratic politics and care little about the social and ecological consequences of their work.

As an aside – can I say when I realised I was living through some of the darkest days in our democratic history, I really didn’t think it would be by a bunch of poorly dressed nerds with a fondness for ketamine and writing long essays about how troubled they are that they are bringing about the end of the world. It’s a form of grandiosity that is so fatuous I find it personally insulting.

Taking back power

There is a lot going wrong with this world but there is also a lot to take heart from. The place I like to start from is Australian’s attitudes to AI.

Everyone is telling Australians that this technology is important – from politicians to financial markets, to a media industry that too often treats industry sources as gospel. Yet in what teeters on a charming form of contrarianism, Australians poll as the least optimistic about AI globally. I like to think of this as our bullshit detector in action. However, across the board people dislike the technology and struggle to see the promise.

More people (79%) report being concerned about negative outcomes than the number (73%) that report experiencing a range of benefits.

Importantly for us, more people see the benefits of rules and accountability. Nearly 90% would be more inclined to trust and use AI if international standards were in place. There is a neoliberal assumption, that people see the state as a laggard bunch of bureaucrats who couldn’t possibly understand new tech, but Australians expect government to step in on their behalf. They want regulation, they want elected representatives to stand up to industry boofheads and that’s a common ground we can work with.

And in fact, we are seeing this start to happen. In recent weeks, Coles announced they are ending their relationship with Palantir. They used the company’s services for workforce and consumer analytics and sustained pressure from Getup with us at Digital Rights Watch have led to them ending the relationship. This is wonderful! The next stage is to target other companies collaborating with Palantir, as well as the tens of millions of dollars’ worth of government contracts so we can get them out of our society.  

In recent days, plans for a controversial $1.2 billion datacentre in Lane Cove in Sydney’s north have been withdrawn, with the developer blaming “emerging” regulations from the state and federal governments for the decision to pull the plug. This is excellent! We absolutely need 21st century infrastructure for the digital age, but what we don’t need is hyperscalers treating us as a place to set up show because they have run out of room in the US.

The government to its credit has tabled reforms to the privacy act (which have been five years in the making) and a proposed digital duty of care, which comes off the back of mammoth litigation in the US that has seen eyewatering sums of damages paid and significant behavioural change.

The Medicare hack by OpenAI agents has seen what I would describe as a paradigm shift in how we understand the threat of AI. Rather than seeing it as a god-like existential threat, or rogue agents, people are coming to understand this as a problem of corporate governance, of cowboys not taking their obligations seriously and an opportunity to hold them to account.

I don’t want to be naive about this, it’s going to take some hard work – the kind of fatigue that comes with defending civil liberties that Thomas Paine knew well.

But I would also argue that these are good conditions to organise around: the overawing hand of power is seeking to crush us, but we have the capacity to land a counterpunch.

There are comically obvious villians, there are clear opportunities for intervention, and the vast majority of everyday people are on our side. This is the time for organisers, agitators, lawyers, ratbags and policy nerds to work together to build an alternative future where civil liberties are protected and democracy can flourish. And it is such a pleasure to be in a room full of exactly those people.